Re: So frustrated! Do you think this is right?
Posted 9/2/2009 12:52:00 PM by cgdg61606
Posted by Bops
Posted by cgdg61606
Posted by Bops
Well, the way I understand it- There needs to be a just cause for a CS increase....When the magistrate asked the BM what the reasons were that she felt that she should be granted an increase- The only reason she could give is that she pays for internet service for my SD to use the computer ....The judge said " Is your daughter the only person in the home that uses the computer?" BM replied yes ....( menawhile she also has a 14 year old DD from a previous relationship)...She also turned down free childcare by me , so the judge could see it wan't about having enough $,...Basically, amongst many other things, BM totally ruined her credibility with the magistarate thus no increase...
The magistrate could tell that she brought him to court out of spite ( BM didn't handle the fact that my DS was born very well and things went down hill from there)
ETA- my DH already pays 50% extra-curricular activities,
100% of health coverage,
50% camp and school related expenses
48% of child-care ( oh yeah, he used to pay 50% but when BM brought him for the increase and the judge did the pro-rata, judge said my DH was OVERPAYING for childcare - BM was NOT happy about that - LOL) So not only did BM NOT get an increase, she ended up with a decrease of sorts !
So sometimes they do factor those types of things in ( meaning if your DH didnt previously pay for sports etc because they were too young, and now that they are older they have additional expenses because of that)
Thank you so much for the info.
So DH was already paying the set % of his current salary for CS and she requested more on top of that?
DH's CS hasn't been ajusted since 2002, but from what i understand, if BM wants it adjusted, she has to bring him to court and therefore pay to bring him to court. Does that sound right?
My DH and the BM were never married...
The BM wrote up an agreement w/ an attorney and my DH hired an attorney to review it and they settled on an amount out of court...It was never a set 17%, it was just an amount that they both agreed was fair at the time....
In the agreement it also outlined the extra-curriculars, schooling, camps, childcare, health coverage etc...They also agreed on that together...
When you go to court, they will ask both parents to bring a W-2, income tax form, and fill out a form regarding personal monthly expenses, bank statements...The judge takes it all into consideration combined...
Just because 7 years has passed does not automatically qualify her for an increase ( in my DHs' case 8 years ) Time is not the only determining factor and neither is increase in the support payers wages...Bluntly stated in the determination that was made to my DH by the court ( they mail you the verdict) it says something to the effect of " It appears the plaintiff ( BM) is merely interested in the respondents increased wages and therfore her request is denied"....Cost of living however is factored in...
As for her having to pay to bring him to court...She doesn't need an attorney to represent her in family court and that is the only expense she would incur if she chose to hire one...There is no fee to apply for a modification
ETA- I really like this attorneys site, here is a list of some reasons for an increase:http://www.sarilaw.com/Family_Law/Modification_of_Child_Support.aspx
Thank you so much for the link and for all of the helpful information!!!
So although DH's salary increased slightly over the last 7 years (nothing significant by any means...), I doubt it would be in her best interest to file for a modification even if she doesn't have to hire an attorney since she now has a job, lives with her boyfriend (her boyfriend's mother to be exact) and DH and I now have a son to support as well now.
This is all so frustrating and difficult!
I am totally stressed right now about so many things...
I have so much anger building up towards her and then I will have to bury it all and put on a happy face and be sweet as pie to her when I have to see her at sporting events, etc. She's extremely phony and is very nice to me in person so I have to be nice to her, but is very hard when I have to deal with all of her nonsense and I know the way she really is!!
Thanks again for sharing your experiences!!
|