Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil?
Posted 8/27/2009 12:41:15 PM by bellaluna


Posted by Ophelia

Beth, I understand what you are saying.

but I am talking about the aftermath...what happens to an ABUSER once he is caught.

Rihanna DID get the police...and this is what he got for what he did to her.

my point is, the LAW treated Michael Vick more harshly. why?

and why do we as people suppose that anything is more or less defenseless when it comes to an abuser? I think that puts too much onus on the abused.

both instances come from a position of trust. the pet trusting the "owner"...and one partner trusting another. and then it's slowly taken advantage of. taken away.

a grown dog can do a lot more physical damage to a man than a woman can (of course, I am not talking about a chihuahua here) if it wanted to fight back.

I think it's unfair to say that a woman can do more.

I think anyone that absues ANYthing is equally heinous.

I don't know....it's just tough for me to swallow I guess.Chat Icon




unfortunately the laws are not strict enough regarding domestic violence. I work in the field and have seen cases far worse then Chris Brown get pled down to a violation because the victim does not cooperate with the DA and they do not have a case to prosecute to the fullest extent of the law , or they have no prior record , or the case gets adjourned for months to years before trial and therefore some witnesses back out, inaccurate reporting of the crime , no 911 tape ....I could go on and on...

It's sad , but in the counties I work in ,you can beat your wife/husband/partner and " get away with it"

I still think what Vick did is worse just because the victim is helpless and domestic violence victims can ( in theory )help their situation more then helpless animals. They can leave and go into a shelter, call the police ,ect. It is much more complex in most domestic violence cases then to "just leave him" especailly when there are children envolved , but it is possible .

Both are disgusting crimes where the perp enjoys being in power and control but I could not work with people who abuse animals or children. Its bad enough I have to be objective with with domestic violence perps, but I cannot stomach animal/child abuse .
Print Post      Close Window