Re: Chris Brown vs. Michael Vick...which is the lesser evil?
Posted 8/27/2009 12:11:36 PM by Celt


Posted by glinda-goodwitch

While an animal can cause more damage with its teeth, I still feel like animals are more defenseless than humans. You can repeatedly abuse an animal and they have no recourse. At least a person can choose to go to the police, file charges, and leave on their own will (unless kept hostage, which is not the case with most domestic abuse). BOTH forms of abuse are horrible and I'm sure it is so hard for a woman to leave this type of situation. But in most causes she has the ability to leave and fight back. An animal doesn't.



This is very much along the lines of how I see it, so I compare Vick's crime more to child abuse than domestic violence. There's a one-sided power imbalance INHERENT in his crime, that is mitigated in the Brown/Rihanna case. While Brown is a complete d-bag lowlife for the way he beat her, she does have access to safety, counseling, and the court system. Children/animals need the law and the legal system to fight on their behalf.
Both cases are tragic examples of inhumanity though.
Print Post      Close Window