Re: "Your Baby Can Read" - Has anyone used this program?
Posted 8/25/2009 4:08:33 PM by cjik
Posted by Goldi0218
The theory has been around for a long time in books. I don't think you need DVD or video to do it. The problem I have with it is that once I go back to work, I will not have the time to devote to it the way it would require.
I do agree with the fact that children do absorb much of what they are to learn in the first few years of life. That being said, I was reading by three years old which by the standards of the 70s is damn good. Shoot, if Abby is reading fluently by the age of 3, I'd be happy and a pig in poop.
Id like to see the balance of how much a child comprehends what they can decode in regard to this program. As a special educator, I have had students who couldn't read a lick off of paper but knew everything that was spoken to them. I have also had students who can decode the Sunday Times but have no idea what they are reading. TO me, comprehension is equally as important.
Personally, I think everything comes in time and I'm not impressed with having this kind of "leg up" as an infant. JMO.
ITA. Yes, maybe your child will learn to read a bit, but will he/she really understand what they are reading? I would rather spend my free time with DS helping him play and develop in other ways--learn to use blocks, do simple artwork, appreciate music, etc. These are all important skills too. Or take him out to parks, museums, the beach, farms, etc. Expose him to things he can see in the world.
Honestly, I think a lot of these products are a bit of a rip off, really not that beneficial to the child and the marketing always preys on parent's fears of their child not being prepared and falling behind others. I don't like that at all.
|