Re: WARNING...Highly upsetting news article in post
Posted 7/28/2009 4:36:42 PM by MrsRbk


Posted by HeathKernandez


Posted by MrsRbk


Posted by HeathKernandez


Posted by MrsRbk


Posted by Nifheim


Now i think if you suffer from a normal PPD that is normal and can be managed but if you have pre-existing physiological disorders you shouldn't be keeping any child.




I will not read this article, but have to say... Wow to this....

I guess I should have my daughter taken away from me then....

Do you have any understanding at all of PPD? What is "Normal" PPD?



she said if you had *pre existing* problems..* not PPD.

I agree with nifheim.



Yes, I read what she said, and I know exactly what she said...so with my *pre-existing* "issues" according to nifheim, I should not be allowed to have children or have my child taken away from me.



obviously you don't because you've misconstrued it and took offense as if she were talking about you...

I personally feel if a person is psychotic, they shouldn't be having children and if they DO... be monitored very carefully.




I didn't misconstrue what she said as talking about me..... I know EXACTLY what she meant. I'm not an idiot. I'm not going to get into my life history on a public message board. Did she touch on a nerve with me... yes... but I completely understand that she was not talking about ME.

She said this:

"Now i think if you suffer from a normal PPD that is normal and can be managed but if you have pre-existing physiological disorders you shouldn't be keeping any child"

I understand 100% she said PRE-EXISTING, I also understand that she said "if you have a pre-existing physiological disorder you shouldn't be keeping any child" I understand the you was not directed at me, but the in the general sense of "you"

What *I* am trying to convey is that there is no "normal" and "abnormal" form of PPD.

I never disagreed that someone who is pshychotic should be monitored and watched if they have children. I agree with that. Nifheim is saying a person with a pre-existing condition should not be able to keep any child.

Again.. I did not read the article, nor will I. I do agree if this woman had a prior history of violent behavior due to her mental state that she should have been monitored as closely as possible.

As I stated in a previous post, PPD or any FORM of PPD IMO is not taken seriously enough and it should be.





Print Post      Close Window