Re: Should everyone get equally?
Posted 3/13/2006 8:41:27 PM by nov04libride


Posted by VirginiaDeb


Posted by Sassyz75

no
i actually red a psychological study that it should be based on NEED.
that actually children like to be treated and recognized to be different and have different needs.



I was also going to say this.


I grew up thinking that everyone should get the same (especially since my mother was so anal about this).

But then I took a class and the professor said that "fairness is not that everyone gets the same, but that everyone gets what they need."

People have different needs and someone should not be given something that they don't need just because someone else got that.

Now, I learned this on an educational perspective... If a child needs to have someone read his test to him because he has a disability, does that mean that everyone in the class should have the test read to them? No, because they don't need it.

As long as everyone receives what they need, then there is fairness.




I agree with this. My mom was just talking about this with me, and she helped me with my wedding...Now some would say my brother deserves the same amount, but he is a lawyer in NYC making $$$$$$$ and though he has law school loans, he is making oodles of money and I chose to be poor and work in education.

I've been thinking about this a lot lately though, and I think it does grown children a disservice to support them well into their 20s. I think when I become a parent I will emphasize giving my children the tools to become self-supporting (paying for education, etc.), but not pay for their rent, food, etc. I feel like when this happens not only do grown children expect this support, but it becomes learned dependence and they do not push or strive to become self-supporting. I've lived a lot of places, and it seems only on LI do I see so many grown children so reliant on their parents to pay their bills and support themselves. When I graduated college I was working on Wall Street and was so thankful for my mom's support throughout college that I spent my first paycheck buying her a computer. It felt amazing to know that I was sone being helped and could finally help in return.
Print Post      Close Window