Re: Rev. Wright says 'Jews' keeping him from Obama
Posted 6/12/2009 4:49:40 PM by Ophelia


Posted by seaside

But my comment was explaining why Jews choose to self identify as Jews. And also to make the point that you just echoed--it's not our place to question it. How can you disagree with that?

I never said anything about any other group; I wanted to stick with the thread's topic of anti-semitism. I have all kinds of good things to say about and against hatred of other groups. Chat Icon



ok, so to be ever clearer, I disagree that they are the only group VIEWED by others simply as "JEWS", as I won't go so far as to fully disagree on how any other group self identifies (meaning, since I don't know how all muslims/catholics/buddhists/lutherans identify THEMSELVES primarily, I won't say Jews are the only people who do that as well.)

I am sure that wasn't very clear at all, Chat Icon but my brain works in mysterious ways.

and yes, I know you mentioned no one else. I did and broadened the discussion. sorry if that led to more confusion.
Print Post      Close Window