Re: Rev. Wright says 'Jews' keeping him from Obama
Posted 6/12/2009 4:47:50 PM by evnme


Posted by seaside


Posted by Ophelia


Posted by seaside



You misread. I didn't speak of any "difference"; I merely said that the jews see themselves as a nation--and they are one. Their haters see them that way too. Only they don't have a border. I wasn't discussing any other group.




sorry, I don't believe I misread at all. I was speaking DIRECTLY to your comments about their situation (being regarded by others as Jews regardless of where they came from) as being unique.

perhaps you disagree with me, which is fine and within your right. but I don't believe our disagreement stems from a lack of reading comprehension on my part.

my point was that haters of "other" people don't distinguish either.

one difference may be that other groups do distinguish themselves by country as well, but I don't hazard a guess as to how one identifies oneself. I don't believe it's my place to do that.



But my comment was explaining why Jews choose to self identify as Jews. And also to make the point that you just echoed--it's not our place to question it. How can you disagree with that?

I never said anything about any other group; I wanted to stick with the thread's topic of anti-semitism. I have all kinds of good things to say about and against hatred of other groups. Chat Icon



several months ago there was a thread on a similar topic and i responded w/ something along these lines: unless you are jewish, you can't truly understand what it means and how it feels to identify yourself the way jews do.
Print Post      Close Window