|
Re: Rev. Wright says 'Jews' keeping him from Obama
Posted 6/12/2009 4:36:09 PM by seaside sorry, I disagree that the "grouping" of Jews regardless of where they came from as unique. ADDED: Never said it was unique--just proper. and I gave examples as to how whether you are american black, african black, island black, or any other black, you are still considered BLACK and still open to the same hate regardless. ADDED: To whom are you still considered black? There are no formalized rules for how people are to be considered; are there? Black people can self identify any way in which they'd like too, as far as I'm concerned...As for the fact that many blacks are hated because they are black--true, and horrible. But what does that have to do wth Jews or the pont that many of us are makng about the way in which jews are identified and self-identify? like I said, the difference isn't nationality or border (which I am pretty sure you referenced in your op) is based on skin color/ethnicity vs. religion. ADDED: You misread. I didn't speak of any "difference"; I merely said that the jews see themselves as a nation--and they are one. Their haters see them that way too. Only they don't have a border. I wasn't discussing any other group. I certainly never started discussing any other group. I'm not sure what we disagree about; my coments were restricted to the anti-semitism that Wright displayed (in the OP) and anti-semitism and how it has shaped jewish identity in general. |