Re: Rev. Wright says 'Jews' keeping him from Obama
Posted 6/12/2009 4:23:38 PM by seaside
Posted by Ophelia
Posted by seaside
This explains why Jews identify theselves as jewish ethnically, something several of us were trying to explain months ago. People don't call out jews by their race or ancestral nation--they call them out as jews and hate them because they are jews--no matter how widely disperesed they become over space and tiime. They have become a hated nation without the borders and sovereign government of an actual nation. It is disgusting and it is something very unique, even among persecuted groups.
see, I have to disagree with this. And I don't mean this to take anything away from Jewish people at all, but racism doesn't distinguish from nationality at all.
if you hate black people, do you think people distinguish between an American black, a Jamaican Black, a Nigerian Black?
or if hispanics/latins are your particular group to despise, do you think it matters if you are mexican, puerto rican, guatamalan, colombian?
or if you hate white people. does it matter if you are american, european, african?
NO
the difference is skin color vs. religion. it has much less to do with borders for any type of hate, and more to do with ways we can lump people together to hate a large group at once.
terrible any way you slice it.
I'm not sure I get what you disagree with. I wasn't talking about what should matter or how other minority groups are judged or persecuted.
Aside from the absolute right of jews to identify as such ethinically if they see fit, it also makes sense that since in the eyes of those who hate and prejudge jews, they are all part of ne despised group, that they would identify as such. If the Jewish people want to identify as a dispersed nation (which I believe they are), who is anyone to forbid them to self-identify as such, irrespective of how other groups experience racism, etc.?
|