Re: ok would you fight it or pay it?
Posted 5/28/2009 12:25:04 PM by LoveyQ


Posted by Sellazz


Posted by Kara

Here's my question - how did the cop know you didn't have it on speaker? That's not illegal and just because he saw you hanging up doesn't mean you were talking with the phone on your ear, you know? I'd say try to fight it and worst case you still pay the full fine, but otherwise you might get it tossed or reduced.



I'm pretty sure the cell phone law states that you must be using HANDS FREE devices while driving. Having your phone on speaker, while holding it in your hand wouldn't be hands free, would it? (Honestly asking because I can't imagine that it would be.)

QUOTE]

You are right -- hands free does not mean speaker phone while you hold the phone. Hands free means headset/bluetooth/ voice activation. You can (and it does happen) get a ticket for even turning off your phone or dialing.



When I've used my cell on speaker in the car, I leave the phone in the cupholder or other spot - I don't hold it, so that's what I was referring to.

As for getting a ticket for turning off your phone or dialing, I actually never heard of that. If that were the case, then people could only ANSWER calls or I guess use voice dialing, but I've never heard of that before. If you're using a headset or bluetooth to make a call, you would need to either dial the number, press a speed dial number, or use voicedial.

I'll be honest here and say that I'm really surprised by some of the harsher comments. The OP was in bumper to bumper traffic and couldn't pull over to make the call and obviously made a mistake which she owned up to. YES, she could have handled it better by using a headset, having the child call, not calling at all, etc., but she didn't and like said before, she'd learn a lesson even if the fine were reduced, so why not try to get it reduced?
Print Post      Close Window