Re: American Idol - 4/14
Posted 4/15/2009 9:42:28 AM by QuackQuack


Posted by nycchic24

I totally agree about the judges. I think its bull what they are doing. Make the show longer..shorten the clips with the mentors..but 2 judges at a time?!?!?!? It loses the whole essence of the show. My honest opinion, get rid of Kara. Why is she there???? They never had this problem before..so its gotta be the 4th judge screwing it up. I hate not seeing Simon respond on everyone..its totally not fair at all.



i completely agree with all of this. I HATE HATE HATE that all of the judges don't get to talk. Simons reviews are my favorite, and I think he is the most honest. I do not care for Kara at all. They also would have more time if Seacrest stopped BSing so much, and all of their clips were a little shorter. I understand that is how we get to know the contestants, but it's not fair when they get cut off, and now they don't all get the same opportunity to be critiqued.

You could see Simon seething last night when he didn't get to speak.
Print Post      Close Window