Re: Please recomend your carseat
Posted 4/1/2009 12:03:28 AM by CarSeatSafety


Posted by SeptemberBride03

We have the Britax Roundabout. We're happy with it so far.

Here are the rankings from Consumer Reports:

Britax Roundabout - Score 81

Evenflo Triumph 5 - Score 81

Cosco Alpha Omega Elite - Score 80

Britax Marathon - Score 58 (this one is much lower and when you look at the whole chart the crash protection score is much lower than the previous three car seats)



I will center my comments on the Consumer Reports. I have not always found their recommendations the best choices for everyone. Over the years some of their choices were the most dificult to use and install. They may have tested well but were not for everyone. Also I still fault them with their report that caused a fear among parents because of an improper test.

Roundabout - great seat, fits most cars easily and easy to use correctly. Only goes to 40 pounds.

Evenflo Triumph, again good seat, but on some cars the adjustment wheel gets locked up in the cushioning of some cars. Straps easily adusted.

Alpha Omega, difficult seat in some cars due to wide base. (Installs better after removing the base) Ony goes to 40 pounds as a car seat. Not recommended to be used as a booster by the Insurance Institute.

Marathon, great seat - fits majority of cars easily, goes to 65 pounds.

Add to the list the Graco line.

The best choice is the seat that you can afford, fits your car the best and can be used correctly by you every time.

The Nautalis is a great seat, but is forward facing only.




Print Post      Close Window