Re: Walmart Spinoff
Posted 3/31/2009 2:51:11 PM by DancinBarefoot


Posted by melbalalala


Posted by CrankyPants

I see what you are saying, but though that may be a fundamental law of economics, it isn't quite that simple and doesn't take into account the human factor. In some areas there is not much choice for jobs. Many people need a $7 per hour job at Walmart as opposed to no job at all and I don't think it means the employment practices are acceptable. Rather, it's job or no job and people who need to feed a family will put up with a lot to do so, it doesn't make it right that they have to.

As a side note, I don't think that Target is much better, it's just that Walmart's issues are more widely known. Shopping at Target vs. Walmart isn't really doing a whole lot for any of the issues discussed in this thread.



Listen CrankyPants.... Chat Icon Chat Icon If that is the case, why don't they move somewhere that has better paying jobs?

I don't mean to come off as heartless, but it is in a person's best interest to get a job that gives them the highest wages/best conditions possible. If that means moving their family, then that's what they have to do. If they choose to stay where they are and take a job that they loathe and get paid $7/hour for, that's the tradeoff that they made.



You're ignoring the reality of the working poor. Yes, it is in a person's best interest to get a job that gives them the best wages/best conditions possible. However, picking up and moving isn't an option for the vast majority of workers that take a job they loathe for $7 an hour. Those people don't have savings accounts - heck most of them don't even have bank accounts. Nor do they have the education to get a higher paying job, or the wherewithal to do research on other parts of the country that might have lower cost of living and better paying jobs for unskilled workers.

Think about what it takes to move. First, you have to find a place to live. Then again, maybe you have to have a job first. Either way, if you're moving out of state, or even just going from Long Island to an upstate county, it costs $$$ to hire a real estate agent, take time off from work, and get to the "new" location to even look at potential residences. If you're looking out of state, the costs of travel, food and lodging are prohibitive for someone earning $7 per hour. If you have a job already lined up that's great, but if you don't, how much time can you afford away from the lousy $7 an hour job to find a new one, in a new place, without somewhere to call home? And don't forget about security deposits, broker fees etc.

That is the reality of the working poor. They can't just find a better paying job.
Print Post      Close Window