Re: Rude or Not Rude
Posted 3/24/2009 4:49:01 PM by dpli


Posted by Lisa

tht might fly in other pats of the country but not here in Ny/NJ/Conn




This is what I was thinking too. It's sort of like the having a cash bar at a wedding debate. I had a roommate that was not from this area and she had no problem with the BYOB/potluck kind of party. I refused to have guests over if I wasn't providing food and drink. Different strokes, I guess, and what you are used to in your social circle.

For me, either have a potluck GTG (either BYOB or not) OR have your kid's birthday party. It almost sounds like they are using their own child's birthday as a reason to throw a grown-up party, but "hey wait, let's make it BYOB/BYOF so we don't have to pay for it."

In the end, though, I agree with Ophelia. If I was close to the child, I would just chalk it up to them being cheap and/or tacky, but wouldn't want to take it out on the child. If I wasn't that close to the family, I probably wouldn't bother going.
Print Post      Close Window