Re: Designer Babies Anyone? POLL
Posted 3/4/2009 1:06:05 PM by maybebaby


Posted by GoldenRod


Posted by azoodie

Okay I may get some flames for this but I honestly don't see the harm in it.

Isn't it already "playing God" to some extent to be doing IVF or those sorts of procedures to begin with? What makes preventing genetic defects any different either - if God wills it who are we to try and prevent it?

To me it's all or nothing. You can't say it's playing God in one case but not in the other. If these embryos are already being tested why not allow them to pick blue eyes or brown hair?




I wrote something similar in the other related thread. Every one of us who has had surgery (including C-sections), antibiotics, vaccinations, etc, have all "played God" in one form or another.....

While I don't necessarily believe in "God", I believe that if there is one, he is allowing us to do this things. An omnipotent being could easily not let us come up with thoughts and techniques to "play God" if he didn't want us to. "The Lord works in mysterious ways." Sometimes the "mysterious ways" may be medicine and genetic manipulation.....



I guess as someone who does strongly believe in God, I tend to think that the plan wasn't to give us science for purposes such as picking superficial traits for our childen. Genetic defects/illnesses are one thing....but hair color, height etc...I just don't understand it I guess. It seems very unethical in my eyes. But that is only my opinion!
Print Post      Close Window