Re: Is this time out working?
Posted 3/4/2009 11:16:19 AM by alexlynn7
Posted by Mikismom
Posted by alexlynn7
Posted by KateDevine
We've been attempting to give Christopher time outs. He doesn't really need them that often, but this is generally the scene when he does:
He does something bad (like today he threw a book at my head, which he thought was funny ) and I took his hand and walked him to the corner and turned him to the wall. He doesn't even last two seconds and then he starts screaming he is sorry. We pick him up and he hugs us for a good 5 minutes, then continues for the rest of the day.
Oh I should also mention, if we want to warn him with "do you want to go into time out" he gets a sad face, stops being bad and says "noooo mama"
So, is this time out working? I can't figure if he is actually realizing it or if he just gets upset b/c he is in trouble?
definitely sounds like he gets that he is in trouble and it doesn't seem like he's going to be the kid who you need to repeatedly put in time out. when you do, though, i would just be very explicit about what he did wrong.
For example:
-he throws the book at your head
-you then say something like "christopher, you don't throw things at people's heads. that hurts people. next time you throw something at someone's head you will go into time out".
-if he makes a sad face and says no, you say ok and redirect him and drop the issue.
-if he throws something at you again, you would then take him into time out. even if he starts crying, you leave him there for at least 30 seconds at his age (about 2, right?).
-when the 30 seconds is up, you would take him out of time out and explain "because you hit me on the head, i put you in time out. you can't hit people on the head with things because that hurts"
-you then take him BACK to the original situation and give him a chance to continue playing and NOT hit you on the head with the book. if he doesn't do it again, move on and drop the issue.
-if he hits you again, you take him back into time out and repeat the process.
sorry so long. hope it makes sense
I agree with everything excpet the time. I was told 1 minute per year of age, so 2 year old = 2 minutes in TO, etc
yup, that's been the rule of thumb for a long time and it's the one i use when i work with families on parent training. but the kids i come into contact are usually 5+ years old...
so i recently asked one of my supervisors about how to do this with toddlers (since she is one of the most published experts about parent training and i am a very inexperienced toddler mom!) and she said that the field is moving in the direction of giving children under 3 less time in TO given their short attention span. apparently it doesn't take too long for them to get the message, and keeping them in TO for longer may end up being counterproductive for some kids (excessive frustration, etc).
i think that in the end, it's whatever works for you, as long as you're following the basic principles and your child gets the message.
|