Re: Why would a 4 year old have a binky?
Posted 2/8/2009 9:31:39 AM by BaroqueMama


Posted by ChrisDee

The truth of the matter is that I have an 8 year old that sucks her fingers still and I guess maybe it frustrated me. Because I would give anything to have something that I could "take away" from her. I have tried everything to make her stop and at this point she cries about it. She wants to stop so bad and she can't. She doesn't even realize when she is doing it anymore. I guess I just feel it is doing your child a disservice by letting them keep the binky too long because the longer they have it the harder it will be to take away, and I guess I feel like those parents are lucky to have the ability to "remove" the issue and I can not chop her fingers off.Chat Icon




Well, I can see where your frustration comes from and from where you're coming. I would personally not allow my 4 y/o to have a binky, especially in public. But that was a battle that I was willing to fight with my child.
On the flip side, my mom brought home a pamphlet from the dentist a couple of months ago and it was put out by the Pediatric Dental Association (or whatever it's called), and they now say that a pacifier and a bottle is fine to use until you lose your baby teeth and as long as the child doesn't use it after their permanent teeth come in, then it's not a problem. So who knows.
I also want to add that people do not believe that my daughter is 2. She has the language and speech capabilities of most 5 year olds and is as tall as a 4 or 5 y/o as well. I still get dirty looks if I put her in the stroller when we go out, and it's really hard to be the one getting stared down because other people don't like a kid who they *think* is too old to be in a stroller. So, I can see your side and I can also see the side of the parent who allows their kid to walk around with a binky at whatever age. Sometimes it's just not worth the fight.
Print Post      Close Window