Re: Let's Discuss Spelling
Posted 1/23/2009 2:27:19 PM by kristinel


Posted by Goldi0218

My response will come across as pompous. Too bad.

I think spelling and grammar is very important. Punctuation is also important, but is rather challenging to master and for me, has always been the proverbial "thorn" in my side.

I hold myself to a very high standard. Sure, I am an educated individual, but I learned the conventions of the English language long before I stepped foot in a university lecture hall.

Exposure to language whether it be through books, magazines or newspapers is just as useful as direct instruction. I know people who can finish the crossword puzzle in the Sunday Times who have nothing more than a high school education. When I ask them how they are able to do it, they say " I read the paper."

In my personal opinion, any decent school program has the responsibility to prepare its students. Granted, there are many students with varying types of learning disabilities that prevent them from certain types of mastery, but for the general public, that is not the case. If English is not a first language or if it is not spoken or reinforced in the home, an extra challenge will present itself as well.

Many times, I have been asked to proofread essays for graduate school and job applications. I am astonished when I see that these people made it through a high school English class. Someone is failing the children if they reach this point as adults. Schools and parents need to take responsibility.

To address the OP. I do think that less importance is placed on spelling. It breaks my heart. As for writing on message boards and in chat rooms, I am smart enough to know when and how to use "chat speak". It has not had an effect on my ability to express myself at all. I have been writing well years before the internet and cell phones were in existence.

Things that I find irksome:

-Mixing of verb tenses in paragraphs and essays
(You would be surprised how many people do this consistently.)

-"A whole 'nother'" versus "another" or "a whole other"
(There is no such thing as the word "nother." You will NEVER see me write it or say it.)

-The fact that people might not think mastery of the basic conventions of English is NOT important.

See? I told you that you would all think my response was pompous. Imagine if I had this same passion for dogs brought into supermarkets? All hell would break loose.

ETA:
People always make mistakes. I make them all the time. At least I look them up. I still use my APA manual from grad school.



Well said. Thank you!
Print Post      Close Window