Re: Gripe Water?
Posted 1/9/2009 2:18:06 PM by wannabemom

I'm a pharmacologist, so perhaps I have bias....

I kept reading threads on using gripe water and was curious what it was.... I recall it being a natural/holistic medicine... I know my opinion won't be popular, but I personally thing holistic medicine is a crock... (the principle behind it is the following: unlike traditional medicines which all require doses on the milligram level... (ex. baby aspirin = 325 mg/ dose), holistic medicine gives unusual substances (usually not studied by the FDA) at doses 1,000-100,000 lower than a normal medication... (ex. 1/10,000 of a mg) Honestly, if this med works, it's a placebo effect. It's medically improbable to be due to a genuine pharmacological action. (I'll spare everyone the scientific reasons why such low doses cannot be effective...) Also, every brand of gripe water has different vague ingredients (ex. ginger extract)... what IS that? how do they extract it? what part of the ginger is tossed out?

so gripe water won't HURT (becuase in essence, there's practically nothing in there! Also, there's no specific recipe)... I just really doubt it will help to the same degree as a genuine medication suggested by a pediatrician...

sorry for the longwinded post.... Personally, I'd give him the real medication under the guidance of the ped....

Print Post      Close Window