Re: Would you be insulted
Posted 12/18/2008 10:19:57 AM by Jax430


Posted by SweetestOfPeas


Posted by Jax430

I wouldn't be offended by the card, but would hope that a close friend would make the effort to write "Happy Chanukah" in order to acknowledge that I do not celebrate Christmas. I think that it would be a little rude for someone to totally disregard the fact that we do not celebrate the holiday at all.

I have received 4 cards like this so far and none of them added "happy hanukkah". they all know me very well, 2 of them are close friends, 1 family member (DH's side) and 1 from my boss.

I didn't give it a 2nd thought. it would have been nice, but I guess I have accepted that I am a minority.



I have accepted that I'm a minority, and that's why I don't get offended by the lack of Chanukah stuff in the stores and things like that. However I do think that if someone is bothering to include me and DH on their holiday card list, they should make the effort to acknowledge the holiday I celebrate.

It doesn't bother me at all if a stranger in a store wishes me "Merry Christmas", but for a friend to do it, just makes me feel like they are completely disregarding my religious beliefs. I have actually never had a friend send me a Christmas card without acknowledging that I celebrate Chanukah. I love receiving cards with pics of my friend's children, and always appreciate that they add "Happy Chanukah."

I certainly am not trying to criticize anyone that has sent Jewish friends cards saying "Merry Christmas". It's just the way I would feel if I were to receive that type of card. I also think that our friends know that DH and I are somewhat observant, so they just wouldn't do that.

ETA: By the same token, I would never send a non-Jewish friend a Chanukah card. I buy separate season's greetings or happy holiday cards and I use those for all of my non-Jewish friends or those in inter-faith marriages, and I always write in "Merry Christmas"

Print Post      Close Window