Re: The pregnant "man"
Posted 11/14/2008 9:27:50 AM by IrishLasss334
Posted by Kara
Posted by Christine
Posted by greeneyes361708
Its not about what he has in his pants.
He feels like he was born into the wrong body. Cutting off your breasts is a bit drastic for someone who just wants to live as a butch lesbian(which was implied on this thread).
Calling this person a woman, when he clearly has done a lot to be recognized as a man, is insensitive and disturbing to me.
It is amazing that people can be so supportive of homosexuals but insulting toward transgendered people.
I completely respect that he feels he was born into the wrong body - I sympathize with it and my heart aches for people that are born with such turmoil. But isn't what Thomas Beatie doing insulting to transgendered people? He was born a woman but feels in his heart and to the core of his inner being that he should have been a man. So he chooses to live his life as a man, oh except he reserves the right to have children.
No, I don't think it's insulting to transgendered people at all. What I DO think is insulting to transgendered people is someone else definitively telling that person what his or her gender is. Telling a transgendered person who identifies as male "No, you're a woman. I don't caer what you say" is insensitive and insulting. I'm glad many people have never had to struggle with their gender identity. I understand that most of us don't understand what that is like. But none of that gives us the right to be so intolerant and insensitive.
I'm sorry, I agree with Christine. Transgender is having the surgery and changing your gender...Thomas has technically not changed his gender, yet,"he" still has a vagina and does not have a penis, so technically he is still a woman. I have family and close friends that have struggled with their sexuality (to be gay, lesbian and bi), I am very sensitive to their feelings. But I think Thomas walking around saying that he is a man having a baby is incorrect, however "he" feels on the inside.
If he was a man putting on a dress, shaving his body hair and even taking estrogen to suppress hair growth etc, he'd still be a transexual, not a transgender, and he'd still be a man.
|