Re: The pregnant "man"
Posted 11/13/2008 6:43:37 PM by Kara


Posted by Jennie0898


Posted by Kara


Posted by JC621

What bothers me most about this couple is that although they are both females, one is "legally" considered a male, and therefore this couple is able to enjoy the benefits that gays and lesbians are fighting so hard for today.



This is a very unfair characterization of the situuation. There is a huge difference between being transgendered and being gay. Not just anyone can go to their doctor and have sex reassignment surgery just because they want it. It involves a lot of time and a lot of therapy and psychological evaluations. Your post makes it seem like you think they're somehow trying to cheat the system or something - but the reality is that being homosexual and being transgendered are NOT the same. I'm ALL for gay marriage; however the way to get there isn't to disparage the rights transgendered people have.



But is this guy considered transsexual or gay?

I was under the impression to be considered transgendered you had to undergo sexual reassignment surgery and that isn't the case for this guy.



Yes, is it the case for this guy. He did undergo sex reassignment surgery. He just chose not to have the female parts removed. If you do. Some searches more info on him came up.

Also, I'm not sure but I believe in order to legally become a different gender you need to have the surgery or be working toward it. (Not sure and would look it up but I'm on my bberry)

I think transgendered doesn't only apply to those who have had the surgery, but also applies to individuals who feel they are truly one gender yet were born another. Surgery is a step they can take. Obviously though when I referred to his rights I was referring to the rights he received after legally becoming a man.
Print Post      Close Window