Re: Newsweek Op-ed article on why McCain lost
Posted 11/5/2008 1:33:31 PM by Kara

That's an interesting take for sure. I do not agree with all of it, though he makes some good points.

I think the Sarah Palin choice backfired - but hindsight is always 20/20. Among more conservative Republican circles, McCain is seen as too moderate. (Not to me, personally, but to a lot of ultra-Conservatives) This is a major reason McCain did not get the GOP nomination in 2000, when (in my biased opinion Chat Icon) he was the best choice for the GOP. I think the McCain campaign was thinking that was still something to worry about and that is why they went with someone who is more conservative than McCain on many social issues. If you watched the analyses of the McCain campaign BEFORE he chose his VP, the buzz was the McCain had to pick someone more conservative than himself or he would lose the conservative Republican vote to third parties. I understand his thinking at the time, though I do believe it backfired in that Palin may have ostracized more moderate Republicans and indenpendents who were otherwise drawn to McCain.

I think this is most telling and a really keen observation I had not considered:




The second mistake was going dark. McCain missed the biggest lesson of the Reagan Revolution: conservatives usually do best when they appeal to America's optimism and develop a positive campaign around a vision for the country. President George W. Bush understood this in 2000, stressing compassionate conservatism, and in 2004 he couched his candidacy in an optimistic argument about how the Bush Doctrine could strengthen America against terrorism and restore the kind of security that seemed lost after 9/11.


This has really got me thinking and I think it's a really good point. If you look back on the campaign, it felt like it was optimism versus pragmatism a lot of the time. Optimism is certainly often more appealing. I appreciate greatly that McCain is a realist, but I see how his campaign could be characterized as "dark" compared to the overall message of Obama's campaign.

The part of the article I don't agree with is its implication that there was no strategy. I think there was a campaign strategy related to the states; I simply think it was less effective. I did not see the campaign as erratic, except perhaps toward the end. Then again, this is just my perception. I tend to feel somewhat strongly that there was a clear strategy that DID work to some extent. Considering the country's disapproval of the current GOP administration and the financial crisis, Republicans had a HUGE uphill battle in this campaign. I actually think the fact that the polls were as close as they were before the election an indication that the strategy was somewhat successful, just obviously not successful enough to overcome those obstacles.

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure there were a TON of things the McCain campaign could have done better. I just don't think it was as haphazard as the article suggests, though it was clearly not effective enough for him to win the race.

I find political strategy very interesting, so this article was thought-provoking for me.
Print Post      Close Window