Re: James Frey admits more lies
Posted 1/26/2006 8:04:51 PM by heidla
Posted by DMcK
Posted by Syliblond81106
Posted by heidla
I'm watching a replay of Oprah and I find her absolutely appalling!!! I can understand the embarrassment, but watching this superiority complex play itself out is truly despicable. I wouldn't be surprised tomorrow if we all read that Mr. Frey has committed suicide or reverted to his old addictions. He made his past out to be more then it was, but he still has recovered from an addiction and should be applauded (just as anyone who does) for it. He wrote a novel that was published as a memoir, his memory, of his encounters. How reliable is a drug addicts memory going to be.
i agree.... i feel bad...she was a rude ****** to him... yes he embellished..but what he embellished was not the true essance of the book-which was his alchohl & drug addiction
I agree that Oprah was too self centered but I don't think you can dismiss Frey's lies. Had they been a few embellishments, I would agree with you but it was deeper than that. There is a big difference between an embellishment for drama or lack of memory and what he did. He wrote lies and went around saying they were truth. That is unethical and wrong. Granted, his story is still inspiring and the shame of this whole thing is that the truth would have been as inspiring and moving.
Other then the time in jail, the manner in which his ex killed herself and the controversy about if he had novacaine or not can someone please tell me the other lies? I also can understand his changing certain things about others in the book. It is his story not theirs and he may have wanted to protect their identities.
I guess I can understand people being upset, but in the end if you found the book to be moving and inspiring I think you can still find it that way.
|