Re: Apparently I am rude
Posted 10/7/2008 11:33:29 PM by puppylove
Posted by MrsPornStar
Posted by Goobster
Posted by lipglossjunky73
Posted by puppylove
Although I am not a fan of people keeping the name a secret until the baby is born, I would never consider people rude for not sharing the name right away. Personally I don't really get the point of keeping it a secret, just as the mommy and daddy having a name for their baby makes it that much more real, I think the same goes for those around you, knowing a name is really fun and people love to hear what the baby will be called so they can begin to address the baby by name also. I couldn't keep it a secret and had to tell everyone! I think that most people are so excited with baby news and hearing what the name will be is so much fun, it's fair for people to be disappointed that they have to wait nine months to be let in on the secret, but considering it rude, no way!
See, thats why we did not share it. The name to us is sacred and I didn't want it to be used and thrown around until he was here, and it was addressed to him. Also, I didn't want to deal with the misprununciations, and why Cailen questions, and people tellng me they didnt like the name, which they would do before he was born....
ITA
I feel until baby is here, it's private and personal. I could change my mind, I could see her and think she doesn't look like a "name" and change last minute. So many reasons that there is no reason to share. My gut just says it's only for DH and I to know until baby is HERE for others to actually physically meet.
This is EXACTLY why we don't want to share his name. I want to see him and make sure the name fits him.
Wanted to restate that although I am not into keeping the babies name a secret, I do not think it's rude for parents to keep the name secret. I understand the reasons why parents would make that choice, really I do. It is a private choice between you as parents and no one should make you feel as if you are rude for making that choice.
Personally, I figure that if people don't like the name they are going to turn their nose up at it whether you tell them before or after the birth. As for everyone "throwing" the name around prior to birth, to me it is nice to hear our families addresses our new addition with a name, rather than "the baby", or "the peanut" or "the little guy", or "it". It makes it more real for everyone involved to have a name. And if it is a tough name, mispronunciation will be a way of life for the child throughout life no only before birth. Also I don't think that by sharing the name before birth means that it is written in stone and can't be changed should she or he not look like a name.
Personally,I'm simply not into keeping such exciting news in, but that's me. You as parents are all free to make your own choices. Your choice to keep the name secret is not hurting anyone and no one should make you feel bad about it, so don't let them make you feel bad. To be honest people who make you feel bad probably don't deserve to know for a while anyway and they deserve to have to wait for giving a pregnant lady a hard time.
|