Re: Catholics to Discuss Voting One’s Conscience
Posted 9/28/2008 7:46:21 PM by donegal419
Posted by wannabemom
hi
I don't mean to trivialize the topic... don't get me wrong, and I know that it's important to Catholics. BUT... here's my political perspective on this...
As a group, politicians LOVE to throw wedge issues (I'm pro-life!) at us so we'll vote for them and ignore their other positions.
Frankly, abortion, capital punishment, gun laws... all of these wedge issues seldom change from administration to administration. Laws are almost never passed...
On the flip-side, the issues I listed in my original post will HAVE to be dealt with by the next president, because they're the issues of the day.
I also get disappointed with the whole right-to-life stance of many candidates becuase it frequently coincides with many 'anti-life' positions IMO. (pro-NRA, pro-capital punishment, a neglect of the poor). It saddens me, but frequently voters must choose to vote their concience on the abortion topic at the expense of turning a blind eye to many other Catholic ethical stances. Capital punishment is another biggie for me, becuase from a religious perspective, IMO, only God should judge man with such a harsh punishment.... not to mention the whole pontius pilate thing and how Catholics were treated in the first 200 years of the roman empire.
hope I didn't ramble on too much. Basically, I view that topic (and capital punishment) as more of an opportunity for politicians to manipulate us than an opportunity for us to express our views and get proper representation...... KWIM?
ITA with you! for me though the disregard we have for human life ( and I am not talking just abortion - i mean the way we treat elederly in this country, our veterans, immigrants, the working poor, etc. etc.) so for me it is not a stance on which i feel manipulated, although neither party is truly for life in ALL facets and stages.
and at the session today, it was so interesting as it was more about what are the issues that we must keep in mind, not a particular candidate or not a particular party. to be honest, IMO, no person with some sense of morailty can be completely happy with either candidate. A LOT was talked about the issues of the day and a list of about 6 intrinsic evils and how depending on the election year, some of the things on the list have to take priority, even though they are all crucial. does that make sense?
|