Re: oooh boy.... the debate....
Posted 9/26/2008 11:41:36 PM by wannabemom


Posted by DandN

Biden's brain surgery was over 20 years ago, right after he ended his first run for the presidency.

I thought it was a tie or a small McCain win - I didnt think anyone delivered a knock out blow or made a huge mistake.

I thought McCain flirted with disaster when he offered a spending freeze on everything except defense, veterans and (I believe) drilling - the last part might be wrong. Obama's response "that's using a hatchett where you should use a scalpel" was great.

I thought Obama missed an opportunity when Milosevic was brought up - he could have used Kosovo as an example to compare with Iraq.

I thought they both looked out of touch regarding the economy. I thought McCain kept clinging to his being the king of earmark reform, but wouldnt get specific on anything else. I thought Obama did a better job outlining his budget priorities - but I didnt think either was strong on the economy.

When they finally switched to foreign policy I thought McCain would run away with it - but I think Obama held his own. I think this part of the debate was great and I really liked seeing their different views (on meeting with world leaders we view as enemies, on what to do with Afghanistan, Georgia, Ukraine, on whether we should have a timetable to pull out of Iraq, etc.)

I think the whole McCain refrain "he doesnt understand" wont play particularly well with independents - going negative really never works well with independents who are as yet undecided. . . and as one commentator pointed out, he runs the risk of looking like a grumpy old man scolding Obama (the commentators words - not mine). The whole Obama "John's right" refrain was (I guess) an attempt to appear bipartisan and presidential. I found myself growing tired of both refrains.

I was pleased that they stuck to strong issues re: foreign policy. I'm really looking forward to the debate on the economy.




yeah, I agree... no one 'ran away with the debate'. it's close to a tie... it's basically up to the fact checkers at this point. they both were throwing a lot of craftily spun 'statistics'.... whomever's exagerations the media criticizes and focuses upon, I believe will 'lose' by monday.


Print Post      Close Window