Re: Windows Vista?
Posted 9/19/2008 8:32:56 AM by Blazesyth


Posted by greenfreak

This opinion is more for experts and not necessarily users:

Put me on the list of computer professionals who choose XP over Vista.



I agree 150%. For an enterprise, there is no real reason to upgrade to Vista over already stable, XP environments. Vista enhancements aren't that significant that there is a good enough ROI for people to actually upgrade many machines to it. Especially considering that the hardware requirements are so high that some organizations would have to not only upgrade their OS, but upgrade their hardware.

In my company we would only have to replace about 10-15% of machines; but we still don't think its worth it. What benefits would people get from it? 'Cooler UI'? Who cares. What would we get out of it? A long migration/integration project and a huge bill for HW/SW that an already strapped IT department doesnt want to touch with a 10 foot pole.

Microsoft knows that they didn't make many changes, and even with Win Server 2008 the same applies. One small 'secret; that we found out from MS folks is that you can take advantage of Win 2008/Vista's MUCH improved GPO management system by the following:

1) Install SP 3 and Client update extensions on all clients
2) Join one Vista desktop to the domain (2003 AD)
3) Install Group Policy Management Console on that Vista desktop.

And bingo - with those 3 requirements you have the same GPO granularity and management features available in Win2008Svr, 2008 Active Directory, and Vista.

The only reason me, as the systems admin would want to go thru the trouble of updating my enterprise to Win2008/Vista is to take advantage of those enhanced management tools. I don't know why MS made it so easy *not* to upgrade to get access to those tools - maybe they got too much pushback from larger enterprise clients, and they realize that the leap from XP to Vista is a costly and difficult one, and they wanted people to get 'hooked' on Win2008 Svr.

Whatever the reason, I'll take it and push as many GPOs as I can. Chat Icon

Print Post      Close Window