Re: Spinal muscular Atrophy
Posted 8/26/2008 9:16:15 AM by Goobster


Posted by secretbabymaker


Posted by Goobster

I am sorry you are dealing with this.

I don't have experience with it, we weren't even tested for it. But just wanted to say...I think that the more they test us for, the more things they are going to find in ALL of us.

I have never even heard of this, how common is it really? All this testing makes me wonder how ANYONE ever has a baby who is healthy (which odds are that a baby WILL be healthy).Years ago, they didn't have any of these tests. When it comes to genetic things, what control do we really have? We can't prevent them, so part of me says must we know EVERYTHING that is a possibility? Sometimes I do think ignorance is bliss, it is very upsetting to know every single thing that COULD be wrong.

Am I making sense?

Chat Icon



You are totally making sense, and it makes me skeptical that they just started testing for it??? No one even really knows what they are talking about when they try to describe to me, I do think your right about the testing, which is why the next time I go to my doctor I am opting out of the AFP, my ultrascreen test came back great and feel no reason to do this, Chat Icon



So they can't even tell you about it? That's odd.Chat Icon As for the AFP, I will speak about this if you don't mind. The ultrascreen does not test for neural tube defects, whereas that is what the AFP is for. AFP can also help detect down's, but it is the only blood test for neural tube defects that we all have a risk for.

That being said, I knew the AFP had a high false + rate. I had the test anyway, b/c I do believe it holds weight in regards to neural tube issues. Lo and behold, my AFP came back as a borderline elevation for a neural tube defect. I was very upset to say the least. My dr told me he believed it was a false + in my case, so practice calls for a retest when you have a borderline elevation. My retest came back great. Had the retest come back abnormal, he would have sent me for a high resolution sono to look at the brain and spine, which would likely clearly show any problems. So IF you got an abnormal AFP for neural tube issues, there is a way they can verify that. What's my point? My point is IMO, I do believe the AFP holds weight and I would do it again if I got pg again. It also can indicate placental insufficiency which would lead to increased monitoring, which would only help you.

There is another poster on here who was in a terrible situation. She did not do the AFP, and found out about a whole month later at her level 2 that her baby had a condition incompatible with life, called anencephaly. She is a big supporter of this AFP testing now.

So I just wanted to share this perspective with you, so you can fully decide if you want the AFP test. But yes, MANY women do OPT out of the AFP in addition. It's a personal choice, but i just wanted to share what I know with you. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window