Reference gone bad, WWYD ??
Posted 7/28/2008 7:13:33 PM by 4monkeys

OK, i'll keep this short and simple and please dont quote. Chat Icon

One of my professors was great. I thought we had a great relationship Chat Icon She gave us all reference letters and said to please use her as a reference.

Well I have used her letter for a few applications, never thought twice about it.


Well back when, I got something at school at Graduation (a small award/scholarship) from a fund set up by another Professor in honor of a late family member. I got the award by submitting an essay. This Prof asked and encouraged many of us to apply for it.

So my Prof asked me to make sure I send them a thank you. Well I will admit, I was 35weeks preggo and had two toddlers, so it took me amonth to send it out (I even have the old emails where I emailed her to tell her it was sent out!! since she kept pestering me, but in a friendly way)

Today someone called her (before hiring me for something part time), I knew they were calling her, I happily gave him her letter as one of my references..

Thankfully my other references were excellent and I got the job. (not a full time position, p/t private company)

this was part of his reply email to me after speaking with her
" I did speak with Professor XXX. She seems to be upset with you over an issue regarding sending out thank yous to people."


Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

I was floored to say the least.

Is this completely unprofessional, is this ok, appropriate?
what would you do ?
I quite frankly want to email her and also the head of her dept, and let them know how completely disapoiinted I am that she did this to me.
Why did she bother giving me a letter?
how many OTHERS has she said this to ? (I havent used her for ALL my applications, but I would say a good portion).
I was great to her, I did lots of extra stuff for her to help her out with class things, I hunted down a restaurant to have a class dinner (she asked me to since she wasnt from the area), I was always there to help out in unrelated (to class) things.. plus I did excellent in her class, so its not like I was a bad student or performed poorly. (she observed me on several occasions in teaching related things)

Im just annoyed with her and want to say something, but Im not sure what.

am I over-reacting?

what would you do ??

It just boggles my mind, because she had even wanted to come by my house for coffee when I had my son (2yrs ago). she was really nice and I thought we were "cool" Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

thoughts??

before I act on instinct Chat Icon

im going to take this down within a day or two, so your advice would be greatly appreciated.
Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window