Re: sorry but another c section post
Posted 7/3/2008 9:32:35 PM by EmmaNick


Posted by ajsmom81507


Posted by dm24angel


Posted by ajsmom81507


Posted by dm24angel

The info is not correct. C sections do not cost the same as vaginals...I worked for health insurance for years and know exaclty how much many Dr's on LI charge for both.

Hosp. Costs for C/s are more as well ( operating room, extra nurse, extra anesthesiologist , IV, And the Dr's get paid more as well as entire recovery room staff.

No OBGYN will approve a womens " request" for a c section unless theres a good reason. And having a child later in life doesnt + a C/s....nor cause reason for one.

Just clearing that up.



My dr. approved of my request for a c section with no reason other then its what i chose, my insurance company approved of it as wellm with no "reason" other then its how i wanted to give birth.

when i spoke to to my dr. he informed me that a C section upon request costs just as much as a vaginal delivery. my insurance company (BC/BS) had told me the same thing.

so... to clear things up here... i had an elective c section by request (1st child) bc it was how i wanted to give birth.... my dr. approved of it immediately (the day i found out i was preggers) and my insurance co. covered it 100%, with no medical "reason" other then i chose to give birth that way.

A study released by HealthGrades, a Denver company that studies healthcare quality, found that approximately 88,000 women had elective C-sections in 2002, up from about 71,000 in 2000, an increase of nearly 25 percent.

The debate over elective cesareans started publicly in the spring of 2000 when then-president of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), Dr. W. Benson Harer Jr., argued for "maternal-choice cesarean" in an editorial printed in the association's journal. Doctors were forced to pick a side as more patients entered their offices with requests. From 1999 through 2002, the number of elective C-sections provided to women with no previous C-section rose almost 42 percent, accounting for more than 2 percent of more than 4 million deliveries. If more women start getting their way, that number could skyrocket. In an online survey at Newshe.com, a Web site put out by sexual health experts Drs. Laura and Jennifer Berman, when nearly 2,500 women were asked, "Would you opt for a C-section over a vaginal delivery if you had the choice?" 37 percent answered "Yes"; another 9 percent answered "Not sure."



Im not calling you a liar, but I worked for Empiure B/C B/S and know for a fact an elective C/S is not covered so Your Dr must have done something to push it through.

I also dont believe your Dr allowed it without any reasoning at all, there must have been a reason.

If there was not, Your Dr. Should not be practicing medicine.

Your reasons are your reasons, And I dont deny you them or your opinions or feelings on the matter but I think the real facts need to be mentioned.



i called BC/BS myself and asked them if they would cover an elective C section bc it was how i was choosing to give birth and they said YES... This is when i was 6 weeks pregnant. so while you say you arent calling me a liar, you are assuming my dr. billed it as medical reasons and thats why they covered, but i knew from calling the insurance company myself.

and you are calling me a liar, by telling me that my Dr. allowed it with no reasoning... bc guess what he DID... and then to say he should NOT be practicing medicine becaese he did.. is just plain stupid and assinine on your behalf... it is a woman CHOICE on how she would like to give birth... it is NOT the dr. choice or anyone else for that matter, your statements are really ignorant and you are severely misinformed on a WOMANS right to choose and todays medicines.

I would love to know why i needed a C section other then i wanted one... please oh great one... tell me... bc by the way you are talking, it seems like you know my medical history, and apparently you are aware of a medical condition that i have that made me have a C section....

please enlighten me....




Interesting. You said you wanted a c-section for no other reason than to have a c-section. Now you say you have a medical condition that made you have a c-section. If you have a medical condition that would make a v aginal birth more difficult, than of course your insurance company would pay for it and I'm sure your doctor coded it accordingly. If you have absolutely no reason to have a c-section, are in perfet medical health and choose to have a c-section for say..the fact that you don't *want* to push, insurance companies don't pay for that, despite what you say and someone that worked for an insurance company has in fact confirmed that.
Print Post      Close Window