Re: C-Sections by Choice
Posted 7/3/2008 7:37:33 AM by Goldi0218


Posted by maybebaby


Posted by Goldi0218

I shall state my opinion then if it wasn't clear.

It is OPINION that what happens between a doctor and a patient is nobody's business.

When people choose to post about choices here, it becomes fodder for three days (case and point in this thread) and people end up doing what they want anyway. I want to believe in my heart that we are influenced by more than what we read here - rather by the medical excellence of the people we entrust with our lives as well as the first few moments of the lives of our precious children. I am sure that many of my prenatal choices have been scoffed at already. In fact, I know they have. Starting from the conception of my child, having an amnio after decreased risk factors at every test, all the way through to the fact that I have consumed cheese, diet soda and cold-cuts throughout my pregnancy.

But without knowing 100% of what happens at each doctor and patient check-up/appointment, without knowing a patient's medical and family history, NONE of us will ever know our rationales for doing what each other does. I do not share everything that happens at each and every appointment or you would all know about my irrational fear of projectile pooping on my doctor's face during delivery and why I plan on warning him to wear a "splash guard" should I deliver vaginally. (OOPS I TOLD YOU but did you REALLY want to know? Didn't think so.)

One can anticipate judgements and they are judgements when they go "against the grain". It is simply what it is. One just has to be prepared for the fall out.



I always have the most respect for what you write and say and agree with so much of it.

However, in this case I just wanted to offer a differing opinion...

I do not think after reading this thread and the OP's question that this is at all about judgment placed on a woman electing a c-section....this has to do with WHY a doctor would offer one so early on in pregnancy.

If the OP had said "I would like a c-section for my own reasons and my doctor is willing to do it" THEN I think it would be judging if everyone attacked and gave the risks behind it..

BUT i honestly think some good information is warranted in a post like this!! ONLY for the sole purpose of enlightening women to the reasons why a doctor would suggest such an involved procedure on a woman so early in pregnancy with no other complications.

It's a very fair thing to question motives, or to post risks, or to really just wonder "OK well why would they offer it?". It helps people understand and maybe read up on things...and in turn OP can go back to her doctor with new information and ask why she has that option now.

Does that make sense?? I would want to know too...so much of pregnancy is told to you as you go by your doctor and it's natural to not second guess them and just "ok" their words. However, in this case, I feel something isn't quite right with what her doctor suggested...and many others would agree I think. That's all!



It's all good and I appreciate the compliment. And you are right, it was not initially about judgement, but in some posts it had evolved into such.

And for the record, yes, 10 weeks is a bit early to decide on that. I thought I was destined for a c-section for an entirely different reason than my baby being breech. I have scar tissue on my cervix and MAY not dilate, but my OB assured me that it is entirely possible for me to have a vaginal delivery. I may find out in just a half hour at my appointment.

I also question what my doctor presents to me which is exactly why I do not already have a scheduled c-section after it was offered to me and I actually do have a reason (odds of which it will correct itself). I question my OB and I questioned my RE before I got PG based on things I read here and then had to slap myself silly realizing that this community, as helpful as it is, did not know every intimate detail of my reproductive history.

I also have a very hard time with medical jargon and information when it is spewed at me in an appointment in a limited time frame. I am not a clinician nor should I be. Perhaps it is a processing issue I have yet to resolve. This is why I bring DH with me to major appointments as he is clear and invested differently in this pregnancy than I am. He decipher's information that I may or may not undrestand or need clarification on.




Print Post      Close Window