Re: Did anyone see the movie BIRTH with Nicole Kidman?
Posted 5/27/2005 10:06:52 AM by FeliciaDP


Posted by marksmama

I am kind of on the fence about this movie. dont know if i like it or not yet.
the only thing I can't figure out is for some reason I think the kids parents set him up, cause they were poor and anna was rich.


Wow .. I never even considered that theory..

Interesting!

I actually left the film kinda/sorta believing that Sean WAS her husband.. And that she knew it in the end also, which is why she had that crazy breakdown.. because really how COULD she have waited for a boy to grow up and become the man she once loved?

THEN my DH explained to me afterwards this: that all along, Sean (the boy) would only remember people when he saw them.. SO he actually had not remembered that when he was Anna's husband that he had been cheating on her with his SIL (anne heche) .. At first, he only recalled the love he had with Anna. SO when he ran into the SIL he remembered he was having an affair, but he didn't want to BE that person , hence the reason he TOLD Anna that he made it up and in fact was not her husband anymore

BUT I'm not buying that theory either completely Chat Icon

ETA: the part I REALLY didnt get was the thing with the letters... WHY would the SIL want to give Anna those letters, and HOW did Sean the boy have them? I guess he followed her to the park to dig them up?

I totally needed to watch that all over again but was too exhausted by the whole thing at that point Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window