Re: I have a dilemna
Posted 5/15/2008 6:44:31 PM by Bxgell2
Posted by 2girlsforme
Beth, I have been there. I'm not a fan of pushing children ahead and neither are most school districts. My youngest missed the cutoff for kindergarten this year by two weeks. She is scary smart but having an older child I wouldn't dream of pushing her ahead for so many reasons. First of all its hard always being the youngest and I don't believe kids are bored today because school, in general, is a whole different experience. I have no doubt that my little one will be "tracked" and will qualify for enrichment.
Being the youngest also becomes a problem when they reach puberty and start driving. From what I've seen with my oldest (who is in 5th grade and is an Oct birthday, we cutoff Dec1), there is a maturity issue. My oldest is almost always the youngest and there are now kids that have developed and have their periods in 5th grade. She is nowhere near that. While I never, at the time, considered holding her back (she made the cutoff by 6 weeks and was reading etc.), if I had to do it again I would and she is a kid that scores in the 99th percentile on state tests and gets enrichment (she's studying Japanese). I guess I'm saying its not all about academics. I found myself frequently pointing out to my daughter's teachers that she was one of the youngest in the room and explaining that although she is sophiscated she is not necessarily mature. On LI it has become popular to hold back kids right on the cusp and imo, its sometimes done for the right reasons and sometimes not.
Interestingly enough, my older one had a playdate yesterday with a kid that is also born in Oct and does well in school etc,. Her mom, if she had it to do again, likewise would have held her back. My oldest starts middle school in Sept (sixth grade) and in some ways the things she will be exposed to make me a little nervous. I have an incredible amount of faith in her, and we discuss everything, but even "good" kids are forced to deal with and navigate around situations that maybe they are not quite ready for.
As for your school, I would for now put her with the older children and see how it goes. If you decide you want her to repeat nursery or Pre K, they will just have to live with it and I assure you they will. What I actually am doing this year with my youngest, is having her do private Kindergarten in her nursery school and have her repeat it in public school. The school district has no idea that she is enrolled in an accredited program and I will not tell them. In addition, her K program is only 8 kids and although it is accredited, you can't convince me that its the same as kindergarten in my school district. In looking at these programs, what I have found is that a lot of them have kids that just miss they cutoff, so imo, the demographic in that room is already skewed.
Sorry for being so long winded. FM me if you want to talk. I just wish someone had explained some of these things to me 5 years ago.
ETA why don't you ask some of the teachers on the board what they think.
TREMENDOUSLY helpful input - thank you. I'm going to xpost on the Teacher Board right now!
|