Re: Naming a child Jr, 3rd, 4th, etc.
Posted 5/9/2008 8:53:28 AM by jprimrose


Posted by GoldenRod


Posted by maybebaby

I'm sorry if this sounds harsh but I can't stand people saying that a child won't have his or her own identity if they are named after their father! How is that possible?? Of course they are their own person and their own unique being..a name is a name!!!

Is it the same thing if someone is the only Ava in their family but are one of 6 in their class?? Do they not have their own identity then?

Sorry I just think that mindset is ridiculous. I come from a family with many of the same names and not once did it ever cross my mind that someone loses their identity...especially when nicknames are used, we have never been confused!



In our society, Jr's DO lose their identity in certain legal aspects. I've named numerous first-hand accounts of people who have had credit problems, mail problem, etc, etc. because they have the same name as someone else. I'm not saying that the child loses their identity, but from a paperwork point of view, they absolutely do. It's just the way our society is set up.

In class, I seriously doubt there will be another child in DC's class with the EXACT same name. Many kids go by "Jim H" vs "Jim M". Part of the name is the same, but they still have a different name.

Socially, they don't lose their identity, which is what you're referring to. A person's name is just a label, not the sum of who they are. You also mentioned that socially, they do have different names. Once someone goes by a nickname most of the time, it differentiates them from their father/son, so they essentially give themselves a different name to avoid confusion.

I'm not trying to start any drama, just explaining why many people don't like the Junioring idea. Chat Icon Chat Icon

DS's middle name is my first name, so I'm definitely not against passing things down. Chat Icon



That is you experience and opinion, which is fine. Other people have different experiences and opinions. There are many adults in my family named after their fathers and none of them experienced the problems you are explaining, and none of them have "changed" their names to differentiate them from their fathers. I think it is great that we all have different opinions and experiences to share with original poster. Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window