Re: Breastfed babies generally "smarter"
Posted 5/7/2008 8:25:13 AM by rojerono
Posted by GoldenRod
Posted by stickydust
I agree about all the other contributing factors. You do not breastfeed or formula feed in a vacuum. I think factors such as genetics, upbringing, etc. contribute more than breastmilk possibly can. Correlation does not prove causation.
Very well written, you obviously were BF'd....
I also don't believe in the BF = intelligent idea. Too many people know too many people who don't fall into the pattern.... DC were formula-fed, but DS is years ahead of his peers in many subjects, and DD seems to be following that trend as well. I think genetics, and upbringing are the major factors. Encouraging DC to learn, always being there for them, giving them whatever they need to advance (education, reading, love and attention, etc).
I agree that it has less to do with the 'breastmilk' itself than it has to do with other factors. The article itself points to the fact that a great deal of breastfeeding mothers are educated, articulate and invested in their children. That does NOT say that all mothers who breastfed are this way - nor does it say that any mother who chooses not to breastfeed is uneducated and neglectful.
I actually did breastfeed. It was not a choice that I made thinking "Wow..my kid will be smart if I do this.."
I think the way we raise our children is far more important that how we feed our children for the first year of their lives.
|