Re: Official American Idol Poll: BO or CARRIE????????????
Posted 5/25/2005 11:13:14 PM by Kierasmom

But it's also a competition and it's a show. They need ratings. Like you said if it's not even close nobody is going to watch it.

And it takes more than singing to make it. Some people crack under the pressure. Some people just don't have the personality. I know someone who has an incredible voice. He tried out, made it through the first round and then lost it in the 2nd round. Couldn't think of the words, just totally fell apart.

I don't think they are looking for the next best singer. I think they are looking for people who are great singers that America will like. Don't forget they have to get people to vote. Mikalah from this season was never going to win because she was way too annoying. She could have had the best voice but america didn't like her.

If it was like Star Search where it was professional judges voting then I would agree that it should be the most talented singers in it. But this is about who america would want.
Print Post      Close Window