Re: American Idol-4/29
Posted 4/29/2008 9:49:23 PM by bluegreen08


Posted by HelenZ


Posted by rose825

so given Paula's mistake, do you think the show is really live?

she seemed to know what was goign to happen, and even Randy said "no only the first song now"



I thought about that too, but then I think she was trying to tell David Cook she was talking to him???? maybe she was trying to say the 2nd singer? not the second song? I think her mind was hiding in a shot glass under the table tonight Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Remember there was some scandal where the recap at the end didn't have the mistake someone made or something? They made it public that the recaps are actually taped from the dress rehearsal because they "dont have enough time to edit the real footage" for the live show.

I'm thinking they probably have the dress rehearsal shortly before the taping because they all wear the same stuff, etc, so maybe Paula forgot she's not supposed to judge based on the rehearsal? Chat Icon I do think it is a live show though.
Print Post      Close Window