Re: Catholics: Something I was struggling with last week...
Posted 4/21/2008 2:57:26 PM by MsMBV

I questioned this exact thing when I was at St. John's. I want to preface my answer by stating that I am not a practising catholic, but I was baptised.

Somewhere along the way, about 300 years after the birth of Christ, men began to put "rules" on the practise of Catholicism (well, all christianity, b.c the reformation had not happened yet). Basically that is when the Ecumenical Councils began, and the "men" of the highest hierarchy in the church began to essentially meet and decide/agree on what the rest of the catholic world would belive/respect/practise, etc. The councils have gone one for years, and still do in recent years.

During the Council of Nicea, I believe, during the time of the Roman Empire, it was determined that Christ was both human and divine. Overwhelmighly so. Bishops from the entire of the known world (exept Britan) were in attendance and I believe only 2 or 3 bishops voted that Jesus was not divine. I believe it is from this original decision of divinity, and precedent of setting doctrine that the bishops eventually were able to claim the Pope Infallible. Also, I am pretty sure that it is not just an "election," I vaguely remember somewhere that there has to be an Apostolic Succession, which relates back to the historic person, St. Peter. And also the cardinals who vote are alleged to be divinely moved to vote and "discover" the Pope's divine spirit.

I'll see if I can find this info & update if I can.
Print Post      Close Window