Re: West Hempstead
Posted 4/12/2008 9:33:35 PM by MrsPowers


Posted by browneyedgirl

although this is a horrible tragedy, i do not support closing campuses for several reasons.

1. these accidents are occurring because of careless/reckless drivers. according to reports, the drivers were speeding and weaving. to punish everyone because of the reckless actions of a few shouldn't happen.

2. most kids leave campus to get something to eat. i know i left my HS every day to get lunch. not only would they not be allowed to leave, the businesses around them would suffer. many businesses near my HS do the majority of their business from the HS kids.

3. many schools do not even have space to hold all of the students at the lunch periods. they would have to expand ($$$) or rework their entire school day. not all schools have cafeterias. those too would have to be built ($$$)

4. making a sweeping law for the entire state based on individual incidents isn't right. to tell all districts that they have to close is not fair. let individual districts decide what is right for their population. although kids in my old HS can walk to lunch spots, the HS in the district i work for is miles away from the nearest restaurant.

again, i feel terrible for these families and the students who lost their lives. it is a horrible tragedy. but to say that closing campuses would stop teen accidents isn't accurate. maybe then they shouldn't allow students to drive to school AT ALL. maybe parents shouldn't give a kid a car at 16/17. if they will speed at lunch time, they will speed getting to school and leaving school.



ITA!!! As a HS teacher at an open campus, it is a privilege and it is quite difficult to take away once the kids have had it already. I imagine if campuses close, then the kids would sneak out anyway.
Print Post      Close Window