Re: IDOL 4/10
Posted 4/11/2008 8:22:55 AM by JP826


Posted by jxnoscar

Honestly I am shocked, but I am so sick of everyone flaming Shyeshia. Fine, maybe her song choices haven't been great but she is the BEST singer IMO on the show.

I am so happy she is safe and while I know I am the minority on here of my support of her, I think that guy sometimes sounded like he was singing karaoke



I have to say.... I completely agree with this!!!!!!!!!!!!

I'm really hoping David Cook will win it all.

I'd just like to make a statement. The judges ate always looking for originality & the contestants get flamed everytime a performance sounds like karaoke. What about David Castro's rendition of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow"? THAT was a total replication of Israel Kamakawiwo's version, yet none of the judges even mentioned karaoke. How unoriginal is that???? Yes, its very hard to make a song "your own" especially when the song / version is so popular, but seriously, I just dont understand why some contestants get flamed for certain things & others dont.

As for Kristy, shes got all her country fans voting for her. The Tiny boppers are voting for Jason Castro & annoying David Archuletta. Brooke was wonderful in the begining, but as the weeks go by, I've noticed thats shes not such a seasoned singer. The 70's syle she has, which although is wonderful, will not be successful in the mainstream. Syesha has a beautiful voice, but shes just so forgetable. Carly, really thinks shes better than what she is & in my opinion is not a true "American Idol". That leaves David Cook which I absolutely love. I feel he has the most talent all around.

Print Post      Close Window