Re: Living together before married/engaged?
Posted 4/10/2008 3:49:57 PM by imagin916


Posted by NinaLemon


Posted by Kara

While we did live together before we were married, I can't say that anything could have come up when we were living together that would have led to divorce if we didn't live together first. It worked for us just b/c it worked for us -- I don't feel I got any extra benefit out of living together first that I couldn't live without, nor do I feel that our wedding night or marriage was any less exciting and wonderful because we did live together first.




I agree, for us, there were not any major hurtles (obviously we are married now) we decided to live together as a financial decision, we knew we were going to get married and wanted to buy a house, we could save more if there was only one apt to maintain. We ended up buying the house before we even got engaged - a little backwards to the taste of most, but to us we already had a commitment and wanted to buy when the market was right. We didn't have to rush out and get married to prove we were ready to buy a house together.

There are a few things I find interesting in this thread, one being the "why buy the cow if can get the milk for free" idea - this really seems like a lack of trust to me, if moving in together means this is a committed or lifelong relationship, shouldn't you trust that the other person is offering you a commitment. To say I won't live with you until you give me a ring, seems like a ultimatum and a lack of trust in your love for each other. If I had to somehow force my DH to marry me, I would not want to be in that relationship.

The other thing I find interesting is, "I know someone who did it and it didn't work out". First, that is a good thing, find out before you get married that you aren't compatible, it makes the break up much easier. My second thought on this is, was the relationship that rocky to begin with, should they have moved into together or did they just like the idea of 'playing house'

As previous posters have said it is a decision which can only be made by the individual couple.



I respect your opinion, but you are saying that you felt comfortable buying a house with your now DH because you KNEW you were getting married. My whole point was, if you didn't know you were getting married or if he said he wasn't sure where your relationship was going, would you still have bought the house with him? My guess would be no, you would not have, which is the point I was trying to make.

I don't think wanting to get engaged or married before living with someone is "forcing" them to marry you, I think it just means that you want to know they are serious before making that type of lifestyle change. There is nothing wrong with that. I wouldn't change my life for someone who is not serious about changing their life for me either. Most guys are not going to get married just to live with you, and I don't think its fair to say that all the women who wanted to wait until engagement/marriage forced thier husbands to marry them. Its complete BS.

Sure, a guy wants to have sex with you on the first date, and if you say no and tell him you want to wait until you get to know him better, is that being "unfair" to him to make him wait until you are ready, even if that means its 10 more dates? I don't think that making him wait for sex is forcing him to take you out 10 more times or whatever. If he likes you, he will have no problem waiting. That is the same logic.

Of course it does work out beautifully for many people, and for some people it doesn't work out. Its a free country, everyone can do what they please and I am not here to tell anyone what they should or shouldn't do, or that anyone else's opinion is wrong, I'm just expressing my opinion like everyone else.
Print Post      Close Window