Re: Living together before married/engaged?
Posted 4/10/2008 2:28:01 PM by imagin916
Posted by Kara
Posted by imagin916
I see what you are saying, but I don't think its the same as renting. I mean, if you are going to pay into a mortgage where you get some equity out of it and the property isn't yours, that is a waste of money IMO. Her parents furnished that entire house and he didn't offer to give her the furniture back or pay for it. That is wrong. At least if you are married and he does something like what this guy did to my cousin, you have legal recourse. If you are just dating you have none.
Someone owns the apartment buildings people rent. A lot of that rent goes toward paying the mortgages, taxes, and other expenses on those properties. So, in a lot of ways, it is like renting.
You are misinformed about your friend's legal rights. If that furnature was a gift to her alone or paid for by her, then she does in fact have legal recourse to get it back. If it was a gift to both her and her ex-boyfriend, then she has legal recourse to get some of it back. Just because she has not chosen to exercise her legal rights does not mean that they do not exist.
And I was using my friend as an example of someone making a really, really poor financial and legal decision while engaged and soon-to-be married. My point was that even with the commitment, you can still make bad legal and financial decisions. I wouldn't marry him either. Then again, my DH and I believe strongly in joint finances. Others have different arrangements. My friend's decisions are not mine to make. I offer advice when she wants it, but I believe in letting other people make their own decisions and mistakes as long as they are informed and know what they're getting into. I can't force my opinion on her.
I am not against what you are saying, I am not trying to argue with you at all, I hope its not coming across that way, but its hard to determine "tone" online you know? I agree that people can make stupid financial decisions no matter what, but at least if the people are married than you have some protection. You didn't pay into a mortgage for years with nothing to show for it, as an example. My cousin probably could sue for the furniture, but who has the time to go to court 100 times over it. I still feel like its different paying a landlord than paying someones mortgage for them, but that is just how I feel.
I am not against people living together at all, I just think that its not always the best solution for everyone, and that many women go into it with much different expectations than men do. Everyone has to examine his/her own situation, figure out what works for them.
|