Re: Living together before married/engaged?
Posted 4/10/2008 2:24:21 PM by Kara


Posted by nov04libride


Posted by PreshusSmurf


Posted by Kara

Your cousin wouldn't have been entitled to reimbursement if she was engaged and likely wouldn't be entitled to full reimbursement even if they were married. I'm not convinced reimbursement in this situation where they were living together would be appropriate, anyway. She was living there, right? Isn't that sort of like paying rent? If I had a roommate at my house paying rent, she wouldn't get reimbursed when she left because I own the house. As for the furnishings, if she did pay for them or half of them, she does have a right to them (or half their value).

Poor financial and legal decisions can be made with or without a ring on your finger. My friend is engaged and will be married in a few months. Her fiance is buying a house only in his name and will close before they are married. He refuses to put her name on the title or mortgage, but she will pay a share of the mortgage. If something were to happen to them and they divorced, she'll have no right to the house, as it won't be considered marital property. She might be entitled to some of what she put into the house, but likely not all or even most of that.

I think this is a very personal decision and support anyone making the informed, intelligent, right decision for them -- regardless of what they choose.

For those who have posted statistics, here's another way to look at them: Link. I just think it's interesting. Also, if you do some research, you'll find that in France, you're LESS likely to get divorced if you cohabitate and after the seventh anniversary in the US, couples who lived together before marriage are no more likely to divorce than those who did not live together.




Thank you for posting this Kara Chat Icon



The article doesn't list any reasons or data that disputes the fact that there is a correlation between living together before marriage and higher divorce rates. As with any study there are factors other than living together that may be at play with the higher divorce rate, and it points out that "People who choose to marry without first cohabitating are already a different group of people than those who decide to cohabitate first.," with different values. Correlation does not equal causation, but if you find a high enough correlation between one condition and a result, that does mean that there is a significant difference between the other group, and this group.

Most research does not have the perfect conditions of random assignments of subjects with all other variables being exactly equal. It rarely happens in psychology or in any other research that occurs outside of a lab. I do data-driven research, and pretty much all of my results say there is a correlation between x and y. Why? Well, there are many, many factors, but the first step is to see that correlation.



I never said it proved the data wrong. I was actually posting the article to show exactly what you just said -- the numbers don't tell the entire story.

As I've said multiple times on this thread already, this is a personal decision that only the couple can make. I don't judge anyone for living together first or for waiting until they are married. What works for me works for me. That's no guarantee it'll work for someone else.
Print Post      Close Window