Re: Living together before married/engaged?
Posted 4/10/2008 2:13:48 PM by imagin916
Posted by Kara
Posted by imagin916
This is JMO, but out of the people I know moved in together, many had a good outcome but more people didn't. My cousin moved into with her bf of 4 years and he dumped her and kicked her out of his house after she was paying half the mortgage and furnished that whole place. She had no right to reimbursement because they were not married or engaged. I have seen instances where the guy is in no rush to get engaged or married because now he has his cake and eat it too. I personally would not live with someone unless we were shopping for rings because I dont have another 3 years to waste. Every individual is different, and you have to make that decision on your own, this is JMO. Good luck in whatever you decide.
Your cousin wouldn't have been entitled to reimbursement if she was engaged and likely wouldn't be entitled to full reimbursement even if they were married. I'm not convinced reimbursement in this situation where they were living together would be appropriate, anyway. She was living there, right? Isn't that sort of like paying rent? If I had a roommate at my house paying rent, she wouldn't get reimbursed when she left because I own the house. As for the furnishings, if she did pay for them or half of them, she does have a right to them (or half their value).
Poor financial and legal decisions can be made with or without a ring on your finger. My friend is engaged and will be married in a few months. Her fiance is buying a house only in his name and will close before they are married. He refuses to put her name on the title or mortgage, but she will pay a share of the mortgage. If something were to happen to them and they divorced, she'll have no right to the house, as it won't be considered marital property. She might be entitled to some of what she put into the house, but likely not all or even most of that.
I think this is a very personal decision and support anyone making the informed, intelligent, right decision for them -- regardless of what they choose.
For those who have posted statistics, here's another way to look at them: Link. I just think it's interesting. Also, if you do some research, you'll find that in France, you're LESS likely to get divorced if you cohabitate and after the seventh anniversary in the US, couples who lived together before marriage are no more likely to divorce than those who did not live together.
I see what you are saying, but I don't think its the same as renting. I mean, if you are going to pay into a mortgage where you get some equity out of it and the property isn't yours, that is a waste of money IMO. Her parents furnished that entire house and he didn't offer to give her the furniture back or pay for it. That is wrong. At least if you are married and he does something like what this guy did to my cousin, you have legal recourse. If you are just dating you have none.
I think more importantly, women tend to see living with a man as a step towards marriage, but the truth is, a lot of times guys don't see it that way. The girl is sitting there thinking oh we are living together, the ring must be coming soon, when the guy may not have that in mind for a long time or ever. I know some guys who lived or currently live with thier gf, and have no intention of ever proposing. Any girl who thinks that its a sure thing that they will get engaged because they live with the guy is fooling herself. As far as the person you are talking about not adding his wife's name to the house after marriage even though she is going to be paying? That is a bad sign, especially since he is just closing on the house a short time before marriage, not like he had the house for years and has it almost paid off and then adding her to it. If I was that girl, he would be out on his azz, no way would I marry him Besides, if they do stay married for a long time and if the house is not in her name, it isnt a guarantee for him either that she will get none of the house. She may be entitled to some of it, so he is stupid thinking that he is totally protected.
ETA: I am not saying that people shouldn't live together before marriage, to each his own, but not to go into it blindly. I know there has been articles and such out there that the divorce rate is not higher, but I wonder what the data is on couples who live together how many wind up actually getting married vs. those who don't?
|