Re: Situation: Was I right or wrong..what would you have done?
Posted 4/9/2008 10:01:59 PM by JenniferEver


Posted by JessInCA


Posted by MrsMerlot

I don't understand how anyone would think that disciplining a child is the responsibility of anyone other than that child's parent.



And I don't understand why some people get all offended when others attempt to help them with that responsibility. She was reinforcing what their mother already told them - to stop - since clearly, they weren't listening to their mother.



Yeah I also felt like if they didn't listen to mom, they might listen to teacher-loady. Some kids will listen to anyone but a parent. Some of my kids behave a lot better when they see me in church.

I didn't scold them. I was firm, but kind. I told them in an informational kind of way, not a "you're bad" kind of way.


ETA: I read the rest of the thread, and I want to reiterate that I did not speak to the children in a derogatory way or raise my voice AT ALL. I also didn't do it in the middle of mass, although my mom said she was tempted to move to sit at the end of their row so they couldn't get out. The mom spoke with the deacon for awhile so it's possible he did say something to her, and he may have approached her about it first, I'm not sure. He and the priest actually both looked kind of appalled a mass, and during the homily the priest did involve the children, and several times he tried to involve these kids, and I think tried to hint to the mom, but she was oblivious. I wasn't unkind or not understanding. When i approached her it was in the same informational tone. I thought maybe she did not really understand. And the kids actually didn't seem wild or disobedient. They just had absolutely no discipline. The mother didn't even try to keep them near her in the pew. Obviously the mother didn't get it. Anyone who gets it will not allow children to disrespect the blessed sacrament.
Print Post      Close Window