Re: Situation: Was I right or wrong..what would you have done?
Posted 4/9/2008 11:54:57 AM by MST9106
Posted by Ophelia
Posted by CrankyPants
Posted by Ophelia
BUT just b/c something upsets YOU does not mean it upsets ALL
But the same can be said about the reverse-just because it didn't upset the mother or the Deacon or all other worshippers, doesn't mean it didn't upset SOME of them and should that play in here somewhere?
IMO-we are living in a society and we have an obligation to one and other. It's not "I get to raise my kids in the manner I see fit and no one else can interfere". These children are going to have to learn how to fit into society and in order for them to be able to do that, disrespectful behavior needs to be checked along the way. It seems clear that the mother wasn't teaching her children to have respect for a church. Maybe the OP helped.
Now, if she yelled at the kids, that would be excessive but to simply tell the kids that they are out of line, that's fine with me. Also-it's not like this is a Walmart or the mall. They are at the same church-there is an even bigger sense of community in a church, and as such even more of an obligation to be respectful.
My mom was a single mom (not that this woman is, who knows?), but I know she needed all the help she could get corralling my brothers and I and keep us in line and had we been monkeying around like this and not listening to her, she would have been thankful to have someone else check us.
the whole point of EVERYTHING that I said is that EVERYONE is different.
I get that it would have been ok with some. but the OP asked about how each individual felt. I am saying how I feel, what I think, and why.
I never said do nothing. I said handle it differently.
there are ways to "check' unruly children without embarrassing their mother.
bottom line: when Jen said something, to those kids, she was not only saying something about THEIR behavior, she was saying something about the mother. In public. based on ONE HOUR of being in her world.
I...me....Ophelia....would not have felt comfortable taking on the assumption that this woman didn't know how to do her job as mother based on this instance and and doing that job for her. period.
Like I said before, I...me...Ophelia...perhaps would have used my knowlege of the church as a teacher of CCD to engage then in whatever object they were currently running around. I've NEVER met a child that didn't like to know a cool secret about something....so that would have been my approach.
No one knows what Jen's tone was...or how it came off to the mother...yet everyone is speaking like they were there...she only said this...she only said that. but no one knows what that mother heard. she was probably embarrassed enough. I couldnt' add insult to injury in such a public way.
Holy Jesus woman...you have A LOT to say!
|