Re: Congestion Pricing Plan
Posted 4/9/2008 10:37:54 AM by cjik


Posted by ilt1221


Posted by ave1024


Posted by donegal419

i am glad it didnt' go anywhere.

1. it would have hurt the people that really need to drive in. workers with equipment, truckers, etc. they are all already up to their eyes with tolls and gas prices, how can you hit them again? it's not effecting the corporate guys with the car service, they can afford it. it's the blue-collar people that were going to get screwed.

2. it would have a disaterous effect on the NYC local economy. the $8.00 or whatever it would be to drive in, would not be spent on that extra cup of coffee or the flowers from the newstands. people would limit additional spending once they're finally in the city.

3. the LIRR, metro-north, the subway are so congested as it is during rush hour. how the heck would they accommodate all those extra people? they can't even afford to have enough trains as it is....i highly doubt the MTA would have done anything additional to ease the crowded trains.

4. people are big-headed.... some would still drive in and it wouldn't really matter too much. how about once and for all improving the buses and trains and having taxi stands. that would really improve the congestion.




Couldn't have said it better myself.

While I typically support Bloomberg and his actions, I can't say I can back him on this one.



ITA! There are other ways to relieve congestion and hey how about having the MTA release some of their surplus $ And to collect this $8 won't there be a bottleneck for tolls? How does that relieve congestion? Obviously the people driving into the city are already spending a bundle in terms of parking expense there is no where to park or in tickets for double parking. There was no way the consumer was not going to pay for it in the end either.



I do agree that some provision needed to be in place for people who have to drive into the city for their jobs--people who do construction, plumbing, deliver products, etc.

I don't think this would kill NYCs economy. As some said, those who have $$$ will keep driving in regardless and will keep buying their coffee. I think it would deter some people from driving in though, one of my neighbors who drives every day was talking about taking the train if this went through. I don't understand why he drives in anyway--we're on a great train line and he works a 10 minute walk from Penn. But whatever, that's a whole other discussion.

One of the plan's biggest flaws in my mind, was not putting plans in effect to expand NYCs transit system. It would be more heavily used, and as some noted, it's overburdened already.

As I said earlier though, I am disgusted that the assembly couldn't even talk about it and put it to a vote and discussion. No alternatives have been presented. I agree with Bloomberg's thought that you can't bury your head in the sand and ignore this problem. Our assembly is soooo backwards.
Print Post      Close Window