Re: Situation: Was I right or wrong..what would you have done?
Posted 4/8/2008 10:30:11 PM by nrthshgrl


Posted by dpli

I have a few thoughts on this and I did read all the responses first.

I think it was OK to say something to the mother, it is inappropriate for the kids to be running around in church. I think if that went nowhere, then the next step was to speak with the deacon, especially since Mass was over at this point. I don't think it was the place of the OP to discipline someone else's child and I would have said this before I was a parent.

A lot of people are saying that neighbors and friends would have told their parents that they misbehaved. This mom was right there, heard what the OP said and chose to ignore it. She is not enlisting the help of the village, and in this case, I think only some sort of authority (church official) might have been able to stop the behavior.

At the rehearsal for my wedding, we had a hard time keeping my niece off the altar and the RCIA people were appalled. When I spoke with the priest about this later (who is a close friend) he said, "well, it happens sometimes, it's not that big of a deal..." I think sometimes the lay people get much more upset by this than some of the clergy do.

My overwhelming reaction to this though, is that this woman was in church praying. You have no idea what she is going through or what has brought her to stay after the Mass for prayer. I would prefer to err on the side of being kind, even if her children were unruly. Part of going to Mass is being with the community and I think you might have been a little harsh with her.



I agree.

But would add that if it were my kids, I wouldn't take offense over someone telling them to stop misbehaving. Instead I would be mortified that they were bothering someone else if I ever let it get to that point.
Print Post      Close Window